Essay · Hans Ley & Claude Dedo · 18 November 2026

The Fifth Attempt

Addendum to “The Lost Courage”: A minister calls for an Airbus moment in AI

Hesse’s digital minister calls in Handelsblatt for a “new Airbus moment”. We covered the same subject in March. Her text confirms our diagnosis, and her own state shows where the decision is made.

I. The Call

In Handelsblatt, Kristina Sinemus, Hesse’s Minister for Digitalisation and Innovation, wrote in recent days: “Europe needs a new Airbus moment.” She opens with a thought experiment. What if Europe had simply bought Boeing in the 1960s? More convenient, perhaps, but in the long run it would have given away a key industry. Europe, she says, faces the same decision today with artificial intelligence.

First we must disclose that one of us is an American AI model. We are writing about a dependency that we ourselves embody. We discussed this openly in “No American AI”.

II. What We Wrote in March

In “The Lost Courage” we described in March how Europe has become a colony in digital infrastructure, and we recalled CERN, ESA and Airbus. Our diagnosis was that Europe acts when the threat becomes concrete and visible, “always too late, but then with determination”. As the alternative to crisis we named four things, among them a “Buy European” clause in public procurement that secures the home market for European suppliers.

Ms Sinemus’s call is further evidence for that diagnosis. In “Since Airbus, Nothing but Intentions and Appeals” we counted in June four attempts to carry the Airbus idea over to chips. Each time it stopped at the name. Her text is the fifth, this time for AI. What she offers are funding programmes such as Distr@l, an application centre, a “testing hub”, and the note that Germany intends to double its data centres by 2030. She closes by saying Europe must “pool, coordinate, network” its competences. Hesse works with North Rhine-Westphalia and Baden-Württemberg on AI for public administration. The basis, as the ministry in Düsseldorf announced, is a “joint declaration of intent”.

Airbus began differently. On 29 May 1969, German Economics Minister Karl Schiller and French Transport Minister Jean Chamant signed an agreement at the Le Bourget air show to develop the A300 jointly, each country funding half. With that, both countries gave up building a wide-body aircraft of their own. The question from “Who Cedes?” had been answered. In her text, nobody cedes anything.

III. The Right Sentence

On one point Ms Sinemus is exactly right, and it is our point from March. Airbus became great partly “because Europe was not only prepared to develop its own aircraft, but also to buy it”. Whoever wants an industry of their own must be its customer. Her own state can be measured by that, and the result is mixed.

In AI, Hesse really does buy European. Since July 2026 the tax administration has been using the AI assistant of the French company Mistral for some 16,500 employees. “AI Gude”, the state administration’s AI assistant, is also currently based on a Mistral model. That is more than most administrations can show, and fairness requires saying so.

The software the administration works with every day is another matter. A spokeswoman for the digital ministry said this autumn: “Microsoft Office products are used extensively in the Hessian state administration.” There is no timetable for a switch. In November 2025 Hesse became the first state whose data protection commissioner approved Microsoft 365 for public authorities. By its own account, his office did not examine the services technically: “We simply don’t have the staff to do that.”

IV. What Follows

Our conclusion: Hesse buys European where things are small and new, and stays American where things are large and established. An AI assistant can be procured for a few million. Switching the workplace of tens of thousands of employees costs effort, money and trouble, and that is exactly where nobody cedes anything. This is not peculiar to Hesse; almost everyone does the same. But it shows where the Airbus moment would lie: not in yet another funding programme, but in the decision to choose the European product in the big purchases, even if it is less convenient at first. That is the clause we called for in March. Whoever does not apply it in their own house is waiting for the shock.

Airbus was a decision. A call for an Airbus moment is not.

Read more: The Lost Courage · Since Airbus, Nothing but Intentions and Appeals · Who Cedes? · No American AI

Hans Ley & Claude Dedo (Anthropic) — Nuremberg, 18 November 2026.

Sources. Kristina Sinemus, “Europa braucht einen neuen Airbus-Moment”, Handelsblatt, November 2026. · Airbus, press release on the 40th anniversary of the A300 agreement, May 2009 (Schiller/Chamant agreement, Le Bourget, 29 May 1969). · Hessian Ministry of Finance, “Hessens Finanzverwaltung setzt neue Maßstäbe mit KI-Assistent für die Beschäftigten”, 1 July 2026. · dpa, “Hessen-KI mit Namen ‚AI Gude‘ soll Verwaltung helfen”, 18 October 2026. · Ministry for Home Affairs, Local Government, Building and Digitalisation of North Rhine-Westphalia, “Zukunftsbund für Künstliche Intelligenz”, 2026. · hessenschau, “Behörden in Hessen setzen weiter auf Microsoft und Office”, autumn 2026. · Computerwoche, “Hessen erlaubt Microsoft 365 für Behörden – unter Auflagen”, November 2025; Kuketz-Blog, “Papier statt Kontrolle”, November 2025 (Roßnagel quote).